Grade archive

Graded D-

A D- on Clad means significant factual issues, heavy partisan framing, or major claims presented without sources — the weakest reports in the band. The full rubric lives on the methodology page.

Browse other grades: A+ · A · A- · B+ · B · B- · C+ · C · C- · D+ · D · D- · F

22 reports, newest first. Full scorecards unlock with a free CladFacts account.

Grade & lean — See grades free

Harry fears Shabana Mahmood security review will delay taxpayer-funded protection

Oct 13, 2026

The TalkTV segment discusses an alleged media war between the Princess of Wales and Meghan Markle, triggered by a video of Kate and daughter Charlotte on the London Underground contrasted with Meghan's Instagram post of Archie and Lilibet on a countryside walk with their dog in the Cotswolds. Hosts pivot to Prince Harry's ongoing bid for taxpayer-funded 24/7 security, fearing delays from Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood's new review of protections for public figures following Ann Widdecombe's killing. Guests argue Harry and Meghan, as non-working royals who left and criticized the family, should pay privately and that posting on social media undermines security claims. Sourcing mixes a Daily Mail article, unnamed 'aides,' public Instagram posts, and Harry's memoir 'Spare.' No direct experts on security policy appear; the throughline is tone-deafness, jealousy toward Kate, and calls for the Sussexes to leave the UK. The segment ends on lighter royal commentary.

▶ Source: TalkTV

Grade & lean — See grades free

ICE shoots father with child in car during Marble Hill arrest attempt

Oct 10, 2026

The MS NOW segment aired footage of Thursday's Marble Hill incident involving pushing between NYPD and protesters, then interviewed Darializa Avila-Chevalier, the Democratic candidate for New York's 13th Congressional District and a democratic socialist who ousted Rep. Adriano Espaillat. She discussed the shooting of Oscar Belgal (also spelled Belgal/Bergal), a 28-year-old Dominican national, while his 5-year-old son was in the car, described his ongoing custody in Brooklyn MDC with the bullet still in his body, criticized DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin's remarks blaming Belgal, and detailed her interactions at the scene questioning NYPD and federal agents' roles. The conversation covered ICE's plainclothes tactics, alleged failure to identify themselves, door-to-door inquiries, and her view that the incident exemplified why ICE must be abolished as an agency inherently enacting cruelty rather than enforcing civil immigration law.

▶ Source: MS NOW

Grade & lean — See grades free

TYT Host Accuses Israel of Smearing Slain Gaza Journalists as Terrorists

Oct 8, 2026

The Young Turks bonus episode features host Ana Kasparian interviewing Sharif Abdel Kouddous of Drop Site News on Israel's alleged smear campaign against Palestinian journalists killed in Gaza. They discuss an IDF list identifying 170 such journalists as Hamas or PIJ operatives, claiming it lacks evidence and is part of justifying killings, including targeted strikes on figures like Anas al-Sharif and Hossam Shabat. The segment criticizes Western media, especially the New York Times and Reuters, for repeating Israeli claims without scrutiny and extends to UAE smear campaigns against U.S. Muslim groups and the post-ceasefire 'Gaza Board of Peace' led by figures like Jared Kushner. They portray the ceasefire as fragile with ongoing Israeli violations and call for ending U.S. arms to Israel.

▶ Source: The Young Turks

Grade & lean — See grades free

Hochul Appoints Letitia James Special Prosecutor in Cornell Fraternity Rape Case

Oct 3, 2026

The broadcast examines the 2024 alleged gang rape of a Cornell student by seven Chi Phi fraternity members, the flawed initial investigation where campus police condensed her interview into a report omitting her clear rape statement, and the local DA's initial decision not to charge. It covers Gov. Kathy Hochul's executive order appointing NY AG Letitia James as special prosecutor for an independent review and grand jury presentation, plus clips from Hochul's press conference and an interview with sex abuse advocate Dr. Caroline Heldman citing 1-in-4 campus rape statistics. Sourcing relies on the civil lawsuit, recent news reports, Hochul and James statements, and the host's prior interview. The throughline links the case to broader Title IX obligations, Trump's higher-ed funding threats over DEI, and his personal history with Epstein and sexual misconduct allegations, arguing these explain federal inaction.

▶ Source: MeidasTouch

Grade & lean — See grades free

TYT Host Cenk Uygur Accuses Ben Shapiro's Family of Nuclear Theft in Fiery Exchange

Sep 2, 2026

The Young Turks segment reacts to Ben Shapiro suggesting certain immigrant families (including Cenk Uygur's) have not benefited America and implying disloyalty. Hosts counter by accusing Shapiro's family of nuclear espionage via his alleged uncle Zalman Shapiro in the NUMEC affair, claiming Israel has cost the U.S. trillions in wars, and alleging Shapiro prioritizes Israel over America. They play a Netanyahu clip interpreted as boasting influence over U.S. politicians and discuss IDF AI targeting tools like 'Where's Daddy?'. The panel defends their patriotism while polling viewers on deportation rhetoric.

▶ Source: The Young Turks

Grade & lean — See grades free

Reuters reports guilty verdict in Keefe D Tupac Shakur murder trial

Aug 31, 2026

The Reuters segment plays audio of a Clark County jury foreperson reading a guilty verdict against Dwayne Keith Davis, also known as Keefe D, on one count of first-degree murder with use of a deadly weapon. Davis requests return of property and notes an appeal. The date given is August 31, 2026. The report relies on courtroom audio rather than named sources or graphics. No additional context on the broader trial, evidence presented, or reactions is provided in the clip.

▶ Source: Reuters

Grade & lean — See grades free

Candace Owens questions surveillance image of Tyler Robinson in Charlie Kirk murder hearing

Aug 30, 2026

The segment features Candace Owens reacting to graphics comparing an alleged unmanipulated image of Tyler Robinson with a version shown during his preliminary hearing in the Charlie Kirk murder case. It claims the court saw a manipulated surveillance photo with distorted background cars and altered aspect ratio that does not match Robinson's skinny build. Owens and the host speculate on who altered it, criticize delayed release of clearer footage, and question the strength of evidence despite the hearing's purpose of establishing probable cause.

▶ Source: The Young Turks

Grade & lean — See grades free

Pentagon drafts tactical nuclear options for regional wars with Russia, China amid Iran conflict

Aug 29, 2026

The segment claims the Trump administration is discussing tactical nuclear weapons use, framed as driven by Israel to enable further Middle East wars including against Iran and Turkey. It dismisses official explanations about Russia and China threats, cites Mark Levin and Netanyahu remarks, labels Israel an out-of-control fascist state seeking US nuclear support, and notes Tucker Carlson's opposition to nuclear first use. The host warns against any normalization of nukes and promises more receipts in a longer video.

▶ Source: The Young Turks

Grade & lean — See grades free

MeidasTouch links Colorado Black Hawk mishap, Apache crashes to Trump military failures in Iran war

Aug 25, 2026

The MeidasTouch segment reports a fresh U.S. Army UH-60 Black Hawk 'crash' in Colorado with no injuries, frames it amid a spike in Apache helicopter accidents due to transmission failures, and ties both to broader Trump administration mismanagement during the 2026 Iran conflict. It highlights an alleged cover-up of casualties, Iranian missile/drone damage to U.S. intelligence sites costing billions, a June Apache downing over the Strait of Hormuz used as war pretext, a Marine One near-miss with a passenger jet, misuse of helicopters by JD Vance and Pete Hegseth, the death of Cmdr. Gabriel Edwards, Pentagon addition of 60 wounded to casualty rolls, an Alaska military plane crash killing eight, and a New Mexico medevac crash linked to GPS jamming tests. Sourcing mixes verified outlets (CNN on Apaches, NBC on intelligence damage, Stars and Stripes on casualties and crashes) with open-source satellite imagery, unverified assertions about hidden pilots and thousands of unreported injuries, and on-screen charts/graphics of losses. No named military experts or administration officials appear; the host drives a through-line of regime incompetence and deception.

▶ Source: MeidasTouch

Grade & lean — See grades free

GB News commentator calls Harry and Meghan's UK return 'desperate'

Aug 20, 2026

The GB News segment features a commentator reacting to reports that Prince Harry and Meghan plan to relocate from California to a private non-royal residence in Britain later in August 2026. Their children, Archie and Lilibet, are set to begin school there in September. The speaker asserts the couple is desperate due to Hollywood failure, isolation in America, dwindling money, and Harry's fear of losing titles, framing the move as proof they erred by leaving Britain and criticizing the monarchy. The clip is an opinion monologue with no named experts, on-the-record sources, or graphics. It draws on longstanding tabloid narratives rather than the recent reporting from the Daily Telegraph, BBC, Guardian and AP that first disclosed the move. No direct response from Harry, Meghan or Buckingham Palace is included.

▶ Source: GBNews

Grade & lean — See grades free

Host links Jackson's 2022 hearing to WNBA transgender controversy

Aug 18, 2026

The broadcast discusses the WNBA trending due to former NBA players Enes Kanter Freedom and Royce White declaring eligibility for the 2027 WNBA Draft by claiming transgender identities, presented as men entering women's basketball. The host repeatedly plays clips from Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson's 2022 confirmation hearing where Sen. Marsha Blackburn asked her to define 'woman'; Jackson replied she could not 'in this context' as 'I'm not a biologist' and would address it as a legal dispute. The segment ties this to broader culture-war claims about gender, biology, and politics. Sourcing relies on the hearing video, host commentary invoking the Bible, Willie Lynch theory, and conspiracy elements; no named experts or league officials appear. Throughline is that failure to define 'woman' at the highest level enables male participation in women's sports.

▶ Source: A Better Black America TV

Grade & lean — See grades free

MSNBC's Lawrence speculates Trump DOJ monitors in Michigan primary were scouting to steal November election

Aug 5, 2026

The segment focused on federal DOJ officials monitoring polling places during Michigan's August 4, 2026 primary election in Detroit, Lansing, East Lansing, and Hamtramck. Host Lawrence portrayed their presence as a suspicious "mystery" potentially linked to plans to interfere in November's general election, especially amid the critical U.S. Senate race where Democrat Abdul El-Sayed narrowly won the primary against Haley Stevens. The broadcast featured Michigan Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson, who won her gubernatorial primary with a record 1.245 million votes, recounting past threats from Trump supporters in 2020 and affirming her commitment to election integrity. Sourcing relied on a DOJ statement identifying monitors as Civil Rights Division and U.S. Attorney's office staff, plus the Lansing city clerk's observations of plainclothes teams mostly staying outside precincts. No on-the-ground incidents were reported. The throughline tied the primary events to fears of Trump undermining Democratic chances to flip the Senate seat in a state Trump carried narrowly in 2024.

▶ Source: MS NOW

Grade & lean — See grades free

GBNews titles Paris metro stabbing with unconfirmed pregnant victim and religious motive

Jul 27, 2026

The segment opens with breaking news on a knife attack in Paris where three women sustained serious injuries and the suspect was arrested. It matches the Dec 26 2025 Paris metro Line 3 incidents at République, Arts et Métiers and Opéra stations. The sourcing relies on the anchor's summary without named experts, graphics or further details; the video title supplies the additional claims about a pregnant victim and the suspect's shouted motive.

▶ Source: GBNews

Grade & lean — See grades free

McConnell hospitalized since June 14 with fall and pneumonia; office confirms recovery amid death rumors

Jul 22, 2026

The segment examines Mitch McConnell's prolonged hospitalization since mid-June 2026 for a fall and mild pneumonia. It explores whether his death could legally remain undisclosed for decades and questions why his staff provides limited updates or proof of life. It cites an MD host explaining death certificate filing timelines, DC vital records rules, HIPAA protections for the deceased, and potential legal risks of falsifying records. The video also discusses Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear's role in a special election and ends by alleging a recent official photo may be AI-generated.

▶ Source: The United Front Show

Grade & lean — See grades free

John James airs ad accusing Democrats of socialist takeover in Michigan governor bid

Jul 21, 2026

The video is a paid campaign advertisement by John James, a sitting U.S. Representative and Republican candidate for Michigan governor in 2026. It opens with his prior warnings on socialism, declares Michigan ground zero for radical Democratic control, and lists grievances including unaffordable healthcare, education content, voting access, Medicaid, and foreign policy sympathies. James highlights his West Point and Army background fighting evil abroad before pledging to defeat it at home with faith and strength.

▶ Source: John James

Grade & lean — See grades free

MS NOW discusses unverified NYT report on Pentagon injury disclosures amid Iran conflict

Jul 20, 2026

Segment features Admiral John Kirby reacting to reported US service member deaths in the Iran conflict, including a 19-year-old, and discussing an NYT report alleging Pentagon nondisclosure of dozens of injuries. Kirby criticizes lack of Pentagon briefings since May, questions strategy amid truce and strikes, and notes Iranian resilience, oil exports during ceasefire, and infrastructure targeting. He highlights benefits to China and Russia and lack of allied coordination. Trump audio clips on 2-3 week military objectives are played and critiqued as not indicating an end to fighting.

▶ Source: MS NOW

Grade & lean — See grades free

Trump pushes SAVE America Act in primetime address reviving 2020 election claims

Jul 16, 2026

The segment features commentary on a recent primetime address by President Trump in which he discussed his administration's record, referenced policies on transgender issues and crime, claimed progress on prescription prices, and promoted the SAVE America Act requiring voter ID and proof of citizenship. It covers his remarks on alleged foreign interference in elections, voter data issues, and a Michigan investigation. The host accuses Trump of hypocrisy on election interference citing his past indictments and describes the speech as demented and aimed at pushing a bill unlikely to pass the Senate. Guests and references include Sen. John Ossoff predicting the content in advance. Sourcing relies on the host's analysis, selective quotes, and Democratic perspectives.

▶ Source: MS NOW

Grade & lean — See grades free

Strickland questions Fugate on alleged election conditions in FY2026 HSGP grants

Jul 15, 2026

The clip shows Rep. Marilyn Strickland (D-WA) questioning former FEMA Administrator Craig Fugate during a House hearing about non-disaster preparedness grants. She alleges that the June 24, 2026 FY2026 Notice of Funding Opportunity for the Homeland Security Grant Program withholds 20% of funds unless states comply with Trump administration election policies, politicizing roughly $200 million in counterterrorism funding. Fugate describes FEMA as being directed by the administration to advance policy until courts intervene. Strickland contrasts this with Fugate's past disaster-response support for elections in New Jersey and Florida and concludes the policy amounts to voter suppression. No other witnesses or documents appear in the segment.

▶ Source: Congresswoman Marilyn Strickland

Grade & lean — See grades free

NewsNation clip revives unverified anecdote on CIA ticks and Lyme origins

Jun 17, 2026

The segment features a reporter recounting an overheard story from a retired CIA operative at a family party who claimed he dropped boxes of infected ticks on Cuba during the Cold War. It links the anecdote to Operation Mongoose, Colonel Lansdale, and a separate interview with Willy Burgdorfer conducted by documentarian Tim Gray suggesting a bioweapons connection to Lyme disease near Lyme, Connecticut. The piece relies on the reporter's personal recollection and references to Burgdorfer's alleged statements, without presenting documents, official records, or opposing scientific views.

▶ Source: NewsNation

Grade & lean — See grades free

Fox segment speculates on Harris role in Newsom family probe amid 2028 speculation

Jun 17, 2026

The segment discusses a recent investigation into California Gov. Gavin Newsom and his wife, speculating that rival Kamala Harris may have a hand in it as they eye 2028 Democratic presidential bids. Hosts Jesse Watters and Benny Johnson engage in extended commentary on Democratic Party dysfunction, Hillary Clinton's potential return, JD Vance's media appearances, and cultural topics like UFC events.

▶ Source: Fox News

Grade & lean — See grades free

NewsNation segment features Royal Navy veteran's UAP account and AI warnings

Jun 16, 2026

The Reality Check segment opens with host Ross Coulthart discussing historical examples of creative 'downloads' or inspirations attributed to figures like Kekulé, Tesla, Ramanujan and Paul McCartney, then links this to modern claims of communications from nonhuman intelligence. It features an extended interview with John Seir (pen name), a former Royal Navy sailor who describes a childhood near-death experience, a 1980s shipboard UAP sighting in the North Atlantic, a subsequent train encounter with a monk-like figure, and ongoing intuitive downloads warning about AI risks to humanity. Seir withholds ship and personal details citing security and loyalty concerns. The segment references Seir's self-published book and notes similar accounts from other viewers.

▶ Source: NewsNation

Grade & lean — See grades free

De Niro criticizes Trump at First Amendment concert

Jun 16, 2026

C-SPAN aired Robert De Niro's speech at the June 14, 2026 'Rise Up, Sing Out: A Concert for the First Amendment' in New York, hosted by Jane Fonda's revived Committee for the First Amendment. De Niro expressed inability to love the U.S. under current leadership, comparing it to an abusive relationship and citing wars, healthcare policy, alleged militia actions, family separations, and personal attacks on Donald Trump as reasons. The segment featured De Niro's remarks as part of a star-studded variety show and protest event with other celebrities; C-SPAN provided straight recording of the public remarks without additional analysis or guests.

▶ Source: C-SPAN

← Graded D · Graded F →